The whole thing is set in a very old time, back when life was raw and regulations were thin. It's about this man who didn't even know his mother or father. He was just a soul brought into a community, almost like a piece of property left there because, at that time, when people were born, they weren't put in registers or registered in hospitals. He was just... there.
He lived that lonely life, never knowing where he came from. He had to figure it all out, fending for himself, and he grew up working as a log man. Cutting wood, selling wood, carrying wood from the mountain—the heavy, back-breaking work of a laborer just making his own way. He was making money from day one, grinding it out, until he met this one girl. And like a switch flipped, he fell in love. She was the one who pushed him to start their life together. They got married, they got a house, and things were good.
But his work was far. He had to travel away for a few days, get back home, and then go again. That was their rhythm. Goes for a few days, gets back home. Goes for a few days, gets back home.
It's that rhythm that leads to everything. His wife got pregnant, and they had a baby girl. And with the kind of work he did, both of them got worried. He was going to miss her growing up. He wouldn't be a part of the child's life.
So they had a plan, a perfect little dream: they would get some land. She would plant on it to multiply their income, and then he would eventually join her as a farmer, and he wouldn't need to travel for work anymore. It was just one last trip. He needed to go out to work this last time, and then he would come back, and they would start their life together, fully, without the distance.
And then it happened. While he was away, a fire broke out in the village. Some areas were consumed, and his house was part of it.
He was just getting off the train—that Train Dreams moment—and he ran straight to his home. He couldn't even get into the place; it was already consumed by the fire. He tried his absolute best to look for his wife and daughter. He didn't see them.

He wasn't sure. Were they dead? Were they alive?
He kept searching, and then he made that heartbreaking decision: he decided to stay right there. He stayed on the land, camping out, just hoping, hoping that his wife and his daughter would eventually come back. He stayed through the winter, through the summer.
He had this one friend—a kind guy who owned a store where they bought simple things like milk and soap. He was so kind, giving him free bread and checking on him.
Then, one day, a dog ran to him. A stray. He took the dog as a pet, maybe to have something warm to hold, still hoping that one day, his wife and daughter would walk out of the woods.
His friend tried to convince him to go to the city, saying the area was too far and remote. But the man just started to build the house again. By himself. Exactly the way he built it when he was with his wife. He built it hoping that maybe, just maybe, when they got back, they would have a place to stay.
He was pouring out his soul, begging God for a sign, a revelation that his wife and daughter were alive.
Sometimes he would just stay alone and cry. That moment when he cried in front of his friend and then apologized for it, because of that mindset that "men don't cry"... man, it cuts deep.
One day, he was sleeping and had a dream. It was a vision that his wife was consumed by the fire. But he didn't see his daughter. So he took that slim hope and ran with it: maybe his daughter was still alive.
Then, he had another dream—so real, it was like he was awake. He saw his daughter come back; she had a broken leg. He treated her and comforted her. And then he woke up, and she wasn't there. It was all in his mind. He was so sad.
He went into the woods and kept looking. Years passed, and he was still looking. He decided to go back to work to get horses so he could start transporting people instead of just logs. He never left that deep, remote bush area. It was his whole world.
One day, he carried a female passenger, who came for nature work in that area; as time went on, they started talking and asked about his family. He told her his family was no more, lost to the fire. And she told him she lost her husband last year.
That moment of vulnerability is beautiful. He tells her the crazy thing: he hears the voice of his wife and daughter playing in the woods, and he doesn't want to look back so they don't go away. He says, "I know it sounds crazy and I never said it to anyone." And she tells him, "It's not crazy." She misses her husband, too, and only people who have not lost somebody really dear to them would not understand this.
After that talk, something shifted. He decided to go to the city. For the first time in years, he saw his face in a mirror. He saw a television and asked a stranger, "What is this?" and they told him it was showing people who went to space. The world had moved on without him.
He saw a place selling cars and those tourist planes for sightseeing. He bought the airplane. Why? Because he had the money. He'd been working and waiting for years, not using the money for anything. He was just using it for himself, which was almost nothing. He hunted, he cooked, and he lived a lonely life.
He started transporting people with that tourist plane. He transported people, and then, quietly, he died in his home. The same home he built for his wife and daughter, the exact pattern of the one that had burned down.
This is where it absolutely crushed my heart: this man never met his wife and daughter again. He never knew if they died in the fire. He had the dream that his wife died, but he wasn't sure about his daughter. He was never sure of anything.
And that imagery... you see the house he built—the one that was supposed to be his happy ending—and after some time, weeds grew and covered it all. This makes me wonder when I go into nature and see those houses built and covered in weeds and trees growing inside, what stories do these places hold?
It just reminds you of the circle of life, doesn't it? And it makes you ask:
How many people didn't get to meet their parents?
How many people had unanswered questions?
How many people didn't get to see the world?
How many people who were enslaved died in another man's land?
How many people who got a lot of questions that could have been answered never got the chance?
How many people who just had memories of the places they come from?
How many people who do not even have any memories?
It saddens my heart that in this time and day, there are still people who want to hurt people, who are mean. Look at this man! He waited. Do people still have this kind of love? I just know in my heart of hearts, I'm that kind of person who has this kind of love. I cannot go without answers.
How do you even make a conclusion in your mind when you don't know if they are alive or they are dead, when you don't know what is happening? It's deep.
This must have been a beautiful book that was written. It really touched my heart, just like the movie Amber Alert.
When you watch the movie, the graphics, the way that house is eventually swallowed by the weeds when he leaves it... it just shows you that at the end of the day, it's vanity of vanity. Those things that you hold so dear, which you carry so much love for, which you want to pass down to generations... it's still vanity. Anything can happen.
It makes me realize... I can't tell you how many people never got to see their parents. And sometimes I'm complaining: "Oh, my dress is not okay," or "I want to eat vanilla ice cream," or "The room is so warm." There are people who never even got the luxury of seeing their parents, who never even got the luxury of seeing where they came from.
Do you even understand the depth of this movie? The certainty of life that can consume one when they don't know or have an answer.
You should think deep and ask yourself, "What is in this world?"
Train Dreams is a moving, deserving tribute to the lonely and the lost.
| Role/Name Used in Movie | Real Name of Actor/Actress | Crew Role | Real Name |
| Robert Grainier (The Log Man) | Christian Bale | Director | Andrea Arnold |
| The Wife | Carey Mulligan | Producer | Graham Broadbent |
| The Daughter (Unnamed) | Elsie Fisher | Screenwriter | Jane Campion |
| The Kind Store Owner/Friend | Bill Murray | Cinematographer | Roger Deakins |
| The Female Passenger | Jodie Comer | Film Editor | Lee Smith |
| --- | --- | Composer | Max Richter |
Do you ever find yourself grappling with life's big, unanswered questions, especially those connected to loss or major life events? I have had this question silently and never told anyone: My question is about my late sister and whether she found peace in the afterlife (heaven). I'd be grateful to hear if others share similar, deeply personal questions they wish they could have answered.

Gracias por la reseña. Aun no me animaba a ver esa película a pesar de las buenas criticas. Tal vez me anime. Te mando un beso
ReplyDeleteI promise you that you will love it, and it carries a lot of weight that will bring you all back to the start and essence of every minute.
Delete謝謝介紹.
ReplyDeleteThank you. I think you should see the movie.
DeleteSuch a powerful review. Even reading your summary made my heart heavy — all that waiting, loneliness and unanswered questions. It really makes you think about the things we take for granted and the loved ones we’ve lost. Gotta watch this.
ReplyDeleteI mean, we have many moments that we take for granted. That is for sure. When I watched this movie, I could feel the heaviness in his heart. I could feel the heavy heaviness in the movie. I was really wishing that they got back. He got back his wife and his kids. The return back to him.
DeleteVery tragic. That's the worst, not knowing. Never knowing what happened to them.
ReplyDeleteWhat happened to his wife and child? The unanswered questions are shattering; they break the sense of the present. I thoroughly enjoyed the film, and it made me think deep.
DeleteWhat a tragic and heart-breaking story. It must be so hard never knowing what happened! xxx
ReplyDeleteIt was really hard to watch him, honestly. But I'm glad I did because it brought up some deeper thoughts and reminded me of something important.
DeleteThis sounds kind of heartbreaking. And you asked some good questions. I have a lot of questions for my parents now, now that they have passed. I didn't think of those questions back when they were alive, but now, it's too late to ask them. Life does throw you curve balls, as this movie surely states. Happy new week. hugs-Erika
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing that, Erika. I hear you, it’s hard when the questions come too late. Life does throw those curveballs, and holding onto memories becomes so precious. Wishing you a gentle week ahead. Hugs back.
DeleteTouching story , Thanks a lot for your review. Will watch Train Dreams soon.
ReplyDeleteThank you! I hope Train Dreams moves you as deeply as it did me, it’s a story that stays with you long after the screen goes dark.
DeleteHi Melody,
ReplyDeleteMelody, I'll write briefly because I'm very worried. My mom has a heart condition and she got the news today that she has to go to the hospital tomorrow. The last diagnosis a few weeks ago was that my mom needs surgery and a heart valve transplant... :( I'm very scared...
Melody, the movie you wrote about is (I can tell from your review) very moving!
Melody, I'm sending you my heart!!!!
Dear Anna, my heart goes out to you and your mom. I will be keeping her in my prayers, asking for strength, guidance, and a smooth, successful surgery. Hold on to hope, and take care of yourself too. Sending you both love and comfort in this difficult time.
DeleteA wonderful review, Melody. I don't get Netflix any more, but this is one I would watch. As for your question at the end of the post. Yes, Some years back, my BIL passed, my sister 2 months later, my brother 6 months later. Being the oldest I took care of everything. Then when my Nan and mom passed it broke me. I think everyday if they are all together, if they are looking over me and my remaining brothers. Do they hear me when I talk to them?
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing something so personal. That kind of loss changes you, and carrying all those responsibilities on your own leaves a mark. I believe those we love stay close in ways we can’t always explain. The questions you ask are the same ones so many of us hold quietly. You’re not alone in wondering, and the love you still carry says everything.
DeleteComo nos dices es una película de esas que cuando acaba te deja un montón de preguntas que hacerte y tratar de contestar.
ReplyDeleteSaludos.
Exactly, Thomas. That’s what stayed with me too, the way it lingers and makes you reflect long after the credits roll.
DeleteUnfortunately, there are many people who want to hurt others...
ReplyDeleteCrazy because they are lost, they even back these people up, and they are also considered normal in some places.
DeleteOlá, Melody!
ReplyDeleteNão tenho a Netflix, por esse motivo não conheço os filmes que por lá passam.
Todavia, os filmes são isso mesmo, filmes. Muitos refletem realidades, outros são meras ficções. É assim também na vida real.
Excelente partlha.
Deixo os votos de boa semana, com tudo de bom.
Beijinhos!
Mário Margaride
http://poesiaaquiesta.blogspot.com
https://soltaastuaspalavras.blogspot.com
Hi Mario. That’s very true, movies can mirror life or take us somewhere completely imagined. Sometimes the ones that reflect reality stick with us the most, even if they’re hard to watch.
DeleteThank you for sharing the story. It was riveting and I could not stop reading it. You are a good writer. Unfortunately, there is a lot of sadness in the world as well as a lot of good.
ReplyDeleteThank you so much, Judee. You’re right. There’s so much sadness, but sharing stories like this reminds us of the strength, love, and resilience that still exist in the world. It’s what keeps the heart holding on. I wont lie i like it when i hear i am a good writer beucase i put alot into my writing. Thank you again.
Delete🎀🎀🎀 Your review touched me deeply; I'll watch it, and Amber Alert too. Right now, I'm watching the serie Yiya, about a serial killer in Buenos Aires.
ReplyDeleteSending big hug and have a wonderful week! 🎀🎀🎀
Thank you, Hada. I hope Train Dreams and Amber Alert stay with you in the best way, and stay safe with Yiya. It sounds intense. Sending a big hug back and wishing you a peaceful, gentle week too.
DeleteI firmly believe your beloved sister is resting in peace.
ReplyDeleteIt sounds incredibly moving and sad. I am not in a mental space to consume sad movies or books right now but thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteI completely understand. It’s not always the right time for heavy stories. Take care of yourself, and thank you for stopping by and reading.
DeleteOch it's so sad :/ I don't know do i want to watch it... i know it will be beautiful but right know i don't feel well for it :/
ReplyDeleteAngelika
I completely understand. Sometimes it’s best to wait until your heart feels ready. The story will still be there when the time is right, and you can experience it fully when you’re ready.
DeleteYou wrote a wonderful review of the film.
ReplyDeleteThank you.
I wish you and your loved ones a wonderful Advent season.
We'll hang up the Advent star on Friday... joy.
Wishing you and your loved ones a warm, joyful Advent season, may the star bring light and happiness to your days.
DeleteWhat an incredible review! You captured the loneliness, love, and unanswered questions in this story so beautifully. It’s a reminder to be grateful and to hold close the people we love. Thank you for sharing this.
ReplyDeleteYou are welcome. The movie deserves an award.
DeleteI thought this movie might be good, but I think I'll save it for a while , as it seems so very sad, and I find the older I get the more difficult it is to handle sad. You wrote a very compelling review. Wishing you a lovely week and weekend ahead.
ReplyDeleteI totally understand you. I literally watched this movie when I was really sad, still sad about what is happening in Nigeria, and it added to my sadness. I should have, but it taught me a lot and reminded me of a lot and made me think about what people have gone through in their lives.
DeleteA great review Melody, so thought provoking. I haven't heard of this film although I see it has a stellar cast. One to watch. Thanks for linking
ReplyDeleteIt is; you should see it. I am sure you will get a deeper understanding than what my post can even present.
DeleteBill Murray 😁 I'm a great fan of him.
ReplyDelete...we will see this Film truely.
Thank you very much for sharing at MosaicMonday
https://happy-hour-with-picts.blogspot.com/2025/11/mosaicmonday-no-163.html?m=1
He did a good job. Class act.
DeleteWitaj Melody. Tak się składa, że też go oglądałam niedawno. Strasznie smutny, refleksyjny niosący dużo pytań o życie. Już dawno tyle łez nie wylałam. Niezwykła historia która uczy nas pewnych prawd. Nie chciałabym być na miejscu tego bohatera który stracił rodzinę. Czasem ciężko się pogodzić z tym co życie nam daje. Nie rozumiemy dlaczego i po co dzieją się rzeczy. Dopiero po jakimś czasie powoli uczymy się akceptować to co nas spotkało.
ReplyDeletePozdrawiam najserdeczniej Melody
I honestly would want to be in his shoes. It is a lot to deal with; accepting such a reality can take years, and some people do not even come to terms with it.
DeleteThank you for the review. It’s such a sad story. I’m sure it’s beautifully photographed, but I can’t handle the tragedy. There’s already too much sadness in life.
ReplyDeleteI can understand; I did not know the movie would end in such a way. I kept waiting for his family to return or just for him to know they are still living, maybe somewhere, but it never happened.
DeleteI've heard of this movie but didn't know anything about it. Your review makes me want to see it now. I love it when the truly Big Questions of Life are asked.
ReplyDeleteI'm so happy you shared this film with FFO. I have watched some trailers, since I don't have Netflix. Wishing you a beautiful day today.
ReplyDelete